EU: administrative authorization for collective redundancy is only in line with EU law when it does not deprive employers of any possibility to make workers redundant

Greek law states that in the absence of an agreement on a 'social plan' with the workers' representatives employers can only undertake any collective redundancy procedures if the labor administration does not oppose such a procedure. The Luxembourg courts do not in principle see authorization by the administration as running counter to EU law and in particular to Directive 98/59 on collective redundancies. Nonetheless in a decision handed down on 21 December, the judges did admit that such authorization could run counter to EU law if the administration's authorization could encourage workers' representatives not to engage in social dialogue in so far as they could rely on the backstop of the administration's refusal to authorize and thus deprive the employer of the possibility of making workers redundant.  The case considered had a cross-border element as it considered a Greek subsidiary of a French business group (Lafarge).  The CJEU added that the administration authorization system intended by the legislation actually runs counter to freedom of establishment as enshrined in the EC Treaty.
Enjoy this article for free while you’re in your trial period
You have access to our content for 1 month.

Directive 98/59 and administrative authorization. From the outset of the dispute on Greek soil, AGET Iraklis, a Lafarge subsidiary, invoked that Greece’s legislation ran counter to EU Directive 98/59 on collective redundancy, which requires worker involvement in the negotiations over and procedure for any social plans. In fact Greek national law says that in the absence of any agreement with the workers’ representatives over a social plan, employers can only proceed towards redundancies if the

Do you have information to share with us?
What you absolutely must read this week
The essential content of the week selected by the editorial team.
See all
United-Kingdom: Day-one rights for unpaid paternity leave
From 6 April 2026, fathers and partners will no longer need to demonstrate six months of service to qualify for paternity leave. This entitlement becomes a day-one right within the company...
30 March 2026
France: CMA-CGM seeks to adapt professional equality to seafaring roles
The news. On 23 March 2026, the shipowner CMA-CGM (17,600 employees in France) and the CFDT, CFE-CGC, and FO unions signed a gender equality agreement for the 2026-2030 period, as identified by...
Germany: crisis and transformation wage agreement in the chemical sector
Following a two-day marathon negotiation in Bad Breisig (Western Germany), the social partners of the German chemical and pharmaceutical industries—the IG BCE trade union and the BAVC employers'...
27 March 2026
Malta: a draft amendment to better protect against workplace harassment
The news. On 23 February 2026, the Maltese government introduced a draft amendment to the Employment and Industrial Relations Act, seeking to expand the scope of protection against workplace...
Most viewed articles of the month on mind HR
What readers clicked on the most last month.
What readers clicked on the most last month.
1
Catherine Chavanier (CDC Habitat): “Social dialogue on AI facilitates its deployment”
In February, CDC Habitat (10,500 employees) signed a two-year framework agreement governing social dialogue on AI. Catherine Chavanier, HR Director of the subsidiary of CDC (Caisse des dépôts et...
2
Greece: hospitality sector signs first collective agreement aligned with National Social Pact
The hospitality sector (125,000 employees), one of Greece’s largest industries after retail, signed a new two-year collective agreement on 17 March. The text, effective from 1 April 2026...
3
France: La Poste to launch negotiations for an AI agreement
Following the lead of firms such as Axa, Syensqo globally, and more recently CDC Habitat, La Poste group management will open negotiations on an AI regulation agreement during the first half of...
4
France: Club Med includes “multiculturalism” in its professional equality agreement
In December 2025, Club Med and the CFTC, Unsa, and FO trade unions signed an agreement on professional equality and working conditions. It introduces measures addressing AI, pay transparency, and...
23 March 2026
5
Germany: crisis and transformation wage agreement in the chemical sector
Following a two-day marathon negotiation in Bad Breisig (Western Germany), the social partners of the German chemical and pharmaceutical industries—the IG BCE trade union and the BAVC employers'...
27 March 2026
6
France: bioMérieux’s new disability agreement pivots towards mental health
The news. On 6 January 2026, bioMérieux—an in vitro diagnostics specialist employing 4,400 people in France—signed a new four-year agreement “relating to the employment...