Germany: Federal Labor Court rules agency workers aren’t systematically entitled to a employment contract, even if they perform an assignment that isn’t “temporary”

In a long-awaited decree rendered on December 10, the Federal Labor Court (BAG) gave satisfaction to an employer who refused to recruit a temporary worker assigned to the company for several years.  The Erfurt judges reminded that, even though the use of agency workers had to be “temporary,” the law doesn’t provide for any sanctions if the temporary nature of an assignment isn’t respected.  The BAG says the lawmaker is in charge of defining the maximum duration of an assignment and determining appropriate sanctions.  Disappointed in the ruling, unions asked the Grand Coalition to implement the provisions of the coalition contract as soon as possible, as they limit to 18 months the duration of a temporary assignment, “to put an end to the inacceptable situation in the temporary industry.”  (Ref.  130791)
Enjoy this article for free while you’re in your trial period
You have access to our content for 1 month.

No sanctions provided for by law. When is an agency worker’s assignment no longer considered as “temporary?” And which sanctions (employment contract?) should be taken against the permanent use of agency workers? On December 10, all eyes were on the Federal Labor Court, whose ruling was expected like a true oracle. However, in the end, the judges refused to decide and sent the ball back to the lawmaker’s court. In a decree in employers’ favor (AZ. 9 AZR 51/13), the Court ruled that an empl

Do you have information to share with us?
What you absolutely must read this week
The essential content of the week selected by the editorial team.
See all
EU: social partners split over competitiveness and action on job quality
The European Trade Union Confederation and BusinessEurope have published their response to the consultation document on the European Commission's upcoming EU quality jobs initiative. The two...
4 February 2026
2026 TRENDS — Social dialogue, a major challenge in the deployment of AI in companies
mind RH is analysing the trends that will shape 2026. Artificial intelligence is emerging as a force that goes far beyond efficiency gains and productivity improvements. It is reshaping tasks...
4 February 2026
The major trends of 2026
New regulations coming into force, economic uncertainty, evolving skills requirements… More than ever, the HR function will play a strategic role within organizations in 2026. mind HR...
Germany: collective bargaining negotiations begin in chemical industry
Collective bargaining talks in Germany’s chemical and pharmaceutical industries are due to open this week, covering nearly 580,000 employees across around 1,700 companies. With the sector facing...
3 February 2026
Most viewed articles of the month on mind HR
What readers clicked on the most last month.
What readers clicked on the most last month.
1
Germany: government seeks to facilitate immigration of skilled Indian workers
During a visit to India earlier this week, German Chancellor Friedrich Merz addressed the strategic importance of attracting Indian workers to Germany, signing a series of cooperation agreements...
2
France: 2026 budget expected to maintain employer contribution relief
On 19 January 2026, French Prime Minister Sébastien Lecornu decided to invoke Article 49.3 of the Constitution to pass France's 2026 budget without a vote in the National Assembly. Three days...
3
EU: Cyprus unveils its six-month presidency programme
Cyprus has set out its priorities for its six-month presidency of the Council of the EU. On the social front, the centre-right government will focus on the Union of Skills, which aims to boost...
4
Informal economy and slow wage growth hamper decent work, ILO says
The International Labour Organisation published its Employment ans Social Trends 2026 on 14 January. It anticipates unemployment stabilising in 2026 and employment growth of 1%, driven by...