Germany: judges rule on the ‘considerable consequences’ needed before a company decision triggers EWC right to information

In a judgment handed down on April 29 2015 over a case between the EWC of an Australian packaging company and both management and its European subsidiaries, the judges at the Lörrach-Radolfzell labor court have decided that the EWC is only apt to lodge a complaint against the group’s European management team and not against the group’s separate national management teams. After reviewing the facts of the case before them they decided there was no obligation to inform the EWC because of a lack of “considerable consequences” related to the group’s decision (a site would be closed with the loss of 70 jobs, and the activity transferred in Poland). The judges held that the amount of fines for cases of non-respect of defined rules in German law over EWCs was not to be challenged and that the German legislator had totally respected the Directive 2009/38 over EWCs.
Enjoy this article for free while you’re in your trial period
You have access to our content for 1 month.

EWC demanded to be informed over exceptional circumstances. The case concerns the closure of a packaging unit in Northern Neumünster and subsequent offshoring to Poland with the laying off of nearly 70 workers in the German unit. From a decision on July 23, 2014 local management declared the redundancies on August 18, 2014. The EWC was informed on the same day. The EWC lodged a complaint challenging what it considered to be non-respect of its guaranteed right to information as intended by Germ

Do you have information to share with us?
What you absolutely must read this week
The essential content of the week selected by the editorial team.
See all
Luxembourg: two pension reform bills submitted to parliament
After lengthy negotiations with the social partners, in mid-October the Luxembourg government submitted two bills to parliament aimed at reforming the pension system to ensure its long-term...
Germany: pensioners in work already common practice, study shows
As the German government steps up measures to encourage people to stay in work beyond the legal retirement age, a new study by the Institute of Economic and Social Research (WSI) – an independent...
France: social conference on labour and pensions to proceed without main employers’ group
The preparatory meeting ahead of the social conference on labour and pensions, which is set to decide on the pension system model and the funding thereof, was held on 4 November at France's labour...
Spain: already well on the way to pay transparency?
Spain is preparing for the implementation of its national law transposing the EU Pay Transparency Directive, which will take effect on 7 June 2026. The legislation marks another step forward in...
5 November 2025
Most viewed articles of the month on mind HR
What readers clicked on the most last month.
What readers clicked on the most last month.
1
mind RH analysis – Initial findings from CSRD social indicators
In 2025, for the first time, the universal registration documents of major European companies contain the sustainability reporting required by the EU Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive...
2
Netherlands: ING cites AI as it plans to cut around 950 jobs
Dutch bank ING has informed the employment agency UWV that it may cut around 950 jobs by 31 December 2026. In its notification on 20 October, the lender said the planned reductions stem partly...
30 October 2025
3
Italy: European pay transparency directive, a major step forward for businesses
Italy’s labour market continues to suffer from limited pay transparency and a persistent gender pay gap. The forthcoming implementation of the EU pay transparency directive — still awaiting...
4
Germany: EU pay transparency directive to force companies to ‘get tough’
Germany introduced a pay transparency law in 2017, meaning companies are already somewhat familiar with the issue. However, the broader scope and stricter requirements of the EU directive, the...
24 October 2025
5
EU: Omnibus Directive clears key milestone in European Parliament
On 13 October, the European Parliament’s position on the Omnibus Directive was approved by its Committee on Legal Affairs by 17 votes to six. Regarding due diligence rules, the report...
13 October 2025
6
Germany: ‘active retirement’ law adopted to encourage seniors to remain in the workforce
On 15 October, Germany’s cabinet approved draft legislation on ‘active retirement‘, which is expected to pass swiftly through Parliament. The bill would allow people who continue...