Germany: a federal labor tribunal has reaffirmed the unions right to negotiate advantages specifically for their own members

In a judgment handed down on April 15. The Federal Labor Tribunal (BAG) recognized that the payment of employee benefits specifically negotiated by IG Metall for its members during talks over a social plan were indeed legitimate. The BAG examined a complaint by a non-member employee who was demanding similar advantages for herself. This ruling is the first decision of this type since a legal precedence ruling that was handed down in 2009.   The confirmation of the legality of the “simple distinction” clause is all the more important   because of dramatic changes in the economic arena, with de-unionization and inter-union competition being two rising phenomena. Being able to offer something more to union members has become an important factor for union bodies.
Enjoy this article for free while you’re in your trial period
You have access to our content for 1 month.

The Federal Labor Tribunal was meant to have ruled on the complaint (Case No. 4 AZR 587/13) by a former non-union member female employee of one of Nokia Siemens Network’s (NSN) subsidiaries. She was claiming special employee financial benefits that had been negotiated between management and IG Metall on April 4 2012.

Do you have information to share with us?
What you absolutely must read this week
The essential content of the week selected by the editorial team.
See all
Croatia: 7.6% minimum wage increase from 1 January 2027
The news. On 29 October, the Croatian Council of Ministers adopted a decree setting the minimum wage for 2027. This will rise from €1,050 to €1,130 gross per month from 1 January next...
UK: trade unions now have a statutory right of access to workplaces 
The news. Since 30 October, British trade unions (certified as independent) have been able to gain physical access to the premises of businesses with more than 21 employees in order to meet staff...
Spain: metal industry employers cut sick pay top-ups
To curb absenteeism, Spanish social partners in the metal sector are introducing new clauses into regional collective agreements to reduce the top-up payments made by employers during sick leave...
2 November 2026
Spain: new rules on working time reduction for caring responsibilities
The news. On 21 October, the Spanish government published a Royal Decree-Law, which came into force on 23 October, facilitating working time adjustments for employees who need to care for a...
Most viewed articles of the month on mind HR
What readers clicked on the most last month.
What readers clicked on the most last month.
1
Ireland: minimum wage increase of 5,6% from 1 January 2027
The info. The Irish government has included a minimum wage increase of 79 cents in its Budget 2027, in line with recommendations from the Low Pay Commission. The rate will rise from €14.15...
2
Denmark: government prepares implementation of pay transparency in March 2027
The news. On 8 October, the Danish executive submitted the bill transposing the European Pay Transparency Directive to the national Parliament. The text stems from an agreement between trade...
3
EU: social partners put the Commission in the crossfire over quality jobs
The news. The second phase of social partner consultation on quality jobs ended on 28 September. A mandatory prerequisite for a social initiative in accordance with the Treaty on the Functioning...
4
China: draft bill to strengthen platform workers’ rights
On 8 October, the Chinese government published a draft bill open for consultation aimed at providing minimum guarantees to non-employee platform workers in terms of pay and working conditions. The...
23 October 2026
5
Is a global wage freeze at Volkswagen possible?
The existence of an option to implement a global wage freeze until 2030 has been confirmed by the management of the German group Volkswagen, which nevertheless provides no details and refers to...
20 October 2026
6
France: paid leave for victims of sexual and domestic violence finally adopted
The news. On 13 October, the French National Assembly unanimously approved, among voting members, the “comprehensive bill” aimed at protecting victims of sexual and gender-based...