Germany: Federal Labor Court limits advantages negotiated for union members only

Preferential clauses are spreading.  The ruling issued by the Federal Labor Court (Case No. AZR 366/09) puts an end to a procedure which has been lasting for two years and concerns a crucial point for unions: strategies to get new members.  In 2009, the Labor Court acknowledged the validity of preferential clauses negotiated between the social partners at company level (see our dispatch No.  090331).  Thus, unions obtained the right to impose wage benefits for their members only, usually an annual bonus ranging between €100 and €400 depending on the sector.  Currently, Verdi negotiates about 70 clauses like this a year, and the IG-Metall 120.  Unions simply explain this practice: unionized employees commit to maintain and improve working conditions and pay, improvements also felt by non-unionized employees.  Therefore, they should be rewarded for their efforts and commitment.
Enjoy this article for free while you’re in your trial period
You have access to our content for 1 month.

al clauses negotiated between the social partners at company level (see our dispatch No. 090331). Thus, unions obtained the right to impose wage benefits for their members only, usually an annual bonus ranging between €100 and €400 depending on the sector. Currently, Verdi negotiates about 70 clauses like this a year, and the IG-Metall 120. Unions simply explain this practice: unionized employees commit to maintain and improve working conditions and pay, improvements also felt by non-unioni

…
Do you have information to share with us?
What you absolutely must read this week
The essential content of the week selected by the editorial team.
See all
France: Bayer puts female health and inclusive parenthood at the centre of its equality policy
In a new agreement on gender equality highlighted by mind RH, Bayer commits to strengthening its parenthood policy. Furthermore, the company is anticipating pay transparency and introducing...
25 September 2026
UK: Government introduces unpaid bereavement leave following a miscarriage
The news. On 22 September, the UK government confirmed the introduction of up to two weeks of unpaid leave in the event of pregnancy loss before the 24th week, in its response to the open...
25 September 2026
France: EDF served formal notice for failure to comply with its sustainability due diligence obligations
The news. On 23 September, Greenpeace France announced that it had served EDF with a formal notice for failure to comply with its sustainability due diligence obligations due to the risks of harm...
24 September 2026
Austria: National Council adopts tax bonus for post-retirement work 
The News. The Austrian National Council (lower house of parliament) passed an active retirement law (Aktivpension) on 23 September. The text introduces a tax allowance of up to €1,250 per...
Most viewed articles of the month on mind HR
What readers clicked on the most last month.
What readers clicked on the most last month.
1
United Kingdom: government launches consultation on AI and data protection rules
L’info. Le gouvernement britannique a lancé, du 15 juillet au 9 septembre 2026, une consultation afin d’identifier les dispositifs juridiques, techniques et de gouvernance...
28 August 2026
2
EU: social partners set out position on guidelines for the sustainability due diligence directive
The news. Following the final adoption of the omnibus directive in February, the European Commission launched a consultation in June aimed at guiding it in drafting guidelines on the application...
28 August 2026
3
Import bans on forced labor products are multiplying
Under pressure from new US tariffs, many countries have presented texts in recent weeks to ban the import of products made with forced labor. A real breakthrough for workers' rights or a mere...
9 September 2026
4
Germany: a “simplification” proposal for the Corporate Governance Code
In early August, the Government Commission presented proposals to reform the Deutscher Corporate Governance Kodex (DCGK), Germany’s Corporate Governance Code. The proposals are primarily aimed at...
31 August 2026
5
Slovakia: a bill to “clarify” personal data protection measures
The news. The Slovak government approved a bill on personal data protection on August 26, 2026. This text aims to clarify existing regulations regarding employees’ rights and...
7 September 2026
6
France: EDF served formal notice for failure to comply with its sustainability due diligence obligations
The news. On 23 September, Greenpeace France announced that it had served EDF with a formal notice for failure to comply with its sustainability due diligence obligations due to the risks of harm...
24 September 2026