France: court decision interprets a clause of an EWC agreement providing for a minimum number of seats for non-French delegates

If a clause of an agreement establishing a European Works Council provides for a minimum representation of delegates from countries other than that of the parent company, does this imply that there can be no additional representatives from those countries? A decision handed down on 28 January 2020 by the Court of Paris, based on the principle of balanced representation provided for in the European Works Council directive and the intention of the parties, states that this clause sets a minimum for representation, not a maximum limit.  
Enjoy this article for free while you’re in your trial period
You have access to our content for 1 month.

This dispute is rooted in a conflict between two French trade union organisations (more precisely regarding the move of a significant portion of the CFDT delegation to the CGE-CGC union). This same dispute had already given rise to a first case (see article n°11112). In the present case, it was a question of interpreting an article on the functioning of the Axa European Works Council (June 29 2009 version) which states: “The GEWC (Group European Works Council) shall have a twelve-member Bureau: this group consists of a Chairperson, a Vice-Chair (appointed by the Chairperson), a Secretary and 9 salaried GEWC members elected by him, five of whom must be from countries other than France.”

Do you have information to share with us?
What you absolutely must read this week
The essential content of the week selected by the editorial team.
See all
British bank Barclays cuts 5,000 jobs to invest in AI
Banking group Barclays has announced the cutting of 5% of its global workforce by the end of the year. Beyond disappointing quarterly results, Barclays primarily intends to free up the funds...
Germany: non-EU recruitment remains marginal despite skilled immigration reform
The news. Nearly a year and a half after the entry into force of the “Skilled Immigration Development Act”, only 4% of businesses have recruited at least one employee directly from a...
France: Orano aims to safeguard the critical skills of its older workers 
The news. On 5 October, French energy and nuclear fuel multinational Orano (15,800 employees in France) and trade union organisations CFDT, CFE-CGC, CGT and FO entered into an agreement intended...
Germany: a negotiation timetable and the prospect of industrial action at Volkswagen
The news. On 23 October, the German carmaker Volkswagen and the trade union IG Metall announced the opening of negotiations on wages, the new cost-cutting programme and job cuts. They will take...
Most viewed articles of the month on mind HR
What readers clicked on the most last month.
What readers clicked on the most last month.
1
Germany: Volkswagen cancels almost all collective bargaining agreements signed with IG Metall
The Volkswagen brand announced on 30 September that it is terminating 10 of its 13 internal collective bargaining agreements, effective 31 December 2026. The announcement, which the carmaker...
1 October 2026
2
Germany: Employers’ representatives seek to limit the rights of works councils
The Employers' Federation of German Employers' Associations (Bundesvereinigung der Deutschen Arbeitgeberverbände - BDA) published a report at the end of September in which it proposes a...
3
France: National Assembly votes for mandatory bargaining on sexual and gender-based violence
The news. On 8 October, French MPs voted to extend the scope of mandatory annual negotiations to sexual and gender-based violence (SGBV). In practice, in addition to pay, working hours and...
4
France: Iliad structures its skills management around AI
The news. On 9 April, Iliad (11,600 employees in France), the parent company of telecoms operator Free, concluded an agreement on jobs and career path management with its representative trade...
5
France: how CDC Habitat aims to better promote the expertise of its employees
The housing division of the French public group Caisse des Dépôts et Consignations, CDC Habitat (10,800 employees), established new measures on skills in July. They are set out in two agreements...
6
France: La Poste strengthens regional management of jobs and skills
La Poste’s 2026-2028 agreement on the management of jobs, professional pathways and gender diversity in occupations puts the emphasis on supporting mobility and career changes, relying on a...